7.2 Aggregated Total Applied Toxicity (ATAT)
1. In decision 16/31 Parties identified pesticide environment concentration and/or aggregated total applied toxicity as headline indicators for Target 7. Parties may choose to report on pesticide environment concentration and/or aggregated total applied toxicity headline indicator, depending on the availability of methodology and in accordance with their national circumstances and technical capacities. Note that the Ad hoc Technical Expert Group established to support the further development and operationalization of the monitoring framework only developed metadata for the indicator aggregated total applied toxicity which is provided below. Metadata for the indicator pesticide environment concentration is not currently available
2026-03-31 00:00:00 UTC
N/A
Target 7: Reduce pollution risks and the negative impact of pollution from all sources by 2030, to levels that are not harmful to biodiversity and ecosystem functions and services, considering cumulative effects, including: (a) by reducing excess nutrients lost to the environment by at least half, including through more efficient nutrient cycling and use; (b) by reducing the overall risk from pesticides and highly hazardous chemicals by at least half, including through integrated pest management, based on science, taking into account food security and livelihoods; and (c) by preventing, reducing, and working towards eliminating plastic pollution.
This headline indicator addresses target element b. For information on the headline indicator related to target element (a) see headline indicator 7.1 ‘index of coastal eutrophication potential’)
2. Chemical pollution can have considerable impacts on ecosystems and biodiversity [1-8]. Pesticides have a propensity for pollution risks due to their outdoor application and their resulting transport into non-target habitats and ecosystems, such as surface waters or field margins [2,6,9-26]. Pollution risks tend to increase with the amounts of pesticides being used. An indicator of pesticide pollution risks should, therefore, take into account pesticide use.
3. Individual pesticide active ingredients affect different components of biodiversity, including different non-target species, to dissimilar degrees [25,27-30]. This is expressed as the toxicity of the pesticide for the particular species or species group. For example, some pesticides are highly toxic to pollinators, whereas others are toxic to aquatic plants. Because toxicities vary, even among chemical compounds belonging to the same pesticide type (e.g., fungicides, herbicides, insecticides) or pesticide class (e.g., based on chemical structure or mode of action), then pesticide use has to be tracked per individual pesticide active ingredient: Total pesticide use or use per type or class is not sufficient [28,29].
4. The headline indicator should ensure that a broad range of species are covered to protect biodiversity as a whole. The indicator should reflect progress towards target 7b, but over-achievement of the target for some species or species groups should not be allowed to compensate for underachievement related to other species or species groups.
5. A low availability of pesticide use data limits the estimation of pesticide pollution risks. Pesticide use data is not publicly available for many countries [31]. In such cases, use has to be estimated from sales, import, export and production data. National indicators established in some countries incorporate additional data for the estimation of pollution risks [19,32-39], but their high requirements for data and analytical capacity make them unsuited as global headline indicators. Aggregated Total Applied Toxicity (ATAT) builds on Total Applied Toxicity (TAT [28]), which requires only active ingredients use and related toxicities as input data. TAT uses compound-specific pesticide toxicities as a weighting factor for the amounts of each applied pesticide in a country. The ATAT incorporates TATs for a range of species groups by pesticides used in agriculture, considered proxies for pesticide risk to non-target species [24,28,29], and assesses changes across TATs relative to an established target and baseline.
6. Currently, pesticide pollution cannot be comprehensively monitored directly. Even with established monitoring programs [12,15,22,23,40-42], the limitations of on-site pesticide monitoring in different environmental compartments (e.g., surface water, soil, atmosphere) hinders comprehensive and accurate risk evaluations at large spatial scales [11].
7. In many instances, pollution risks associated with other highly hazardous chemicals, other than pesticides, do not emerge from direct outdoor applications. This headline indicator cannot track pollution risks from these chemicals. Complementary indicators may be developed to track the target for these chemicals.
.8. Pesticides are any substance or mixture of substances—chemical or biological—intended to repel, destroy, or control pests, including vectors of human or animal disease, unwanted species of plants or animals causing harm during production, processing, storage, or transport of food and agricultural commodities [43]. Pesticides are understood here as active ingredients, i.e., chemical compounds, and not as products. Approximately 600 pesticides, for which toxicity data are available for a large number of species groups [29], form the basis for ATAT calculations in each country (see 5e Data sources). These include pesticides of various types (e.g., fungicides, herbicides, insecticides) that are mainly synthetic chemicals and mainly used outdoors.
9. Pesticide use is the amount of a pesticide active ingredient (in kg) applied within a country and a year. Where this use data is not available through government records or survey-based market research, it can be estimated using sales, import, export, and production data. Only outdoor pesticide use, including seed treatments, should be included in ATAT calculations; other uses, for example in greenhouses or storage, should be excluded. When outdoor uses are not reported separately for pesticides that are mainly used outdoors, then these pesticides should also be included for ATAT calculations.
10. A range of species groups, each with species that have similar taxonomic or functional properties, represent the species diversity component of biodiversity [29]. Together, these groups are considered as the broadest possible representation of biodiversity in the context of species groups for which pesticide toxicity data are available. Species groups are defined during pesticide risk assessments in countries that implement pesticide regulatory frameworks. The ATAT uses a set of nine species groups that are commonly considered under pesticide regulatory frameworks, these are: aquatic invertebrates, aquatic plants, fish, terrestrial arthropods (excluding pollinators), pollinators, birds, mammals, soil organisms and terrestrial plants. An advantage of considering different species groups is the possibility to identify leverage points for effective management decisions, such as substituting more toxic with less toxic pesticide alternatives [29]. Further details regarding the coverage of species groups are provided in section 5e.
11. Regulatory frameworks have been established in some countries and regions to proactively evaluate and manage risks from pesticide use. Within these frameworks, considerable information on pesticide toxicities is accumulated with a high level of standardization, allowing comparisons of acute or chronic toxicity data between a large number of pesticides. Data and methodologies from regulatory frameworks, harmonized for global representativeness, are the main source of toxicity estimates for ATAT calculations. The toxicity of a pesticide refers to the amount of pesticide in a medium (or organism) that results in specific effects, commonly derived from laboratory tests [28,35,44]. Toxicities are expressed as a single value for each pesticide active ingredient for a species (where data is available, toxicities for adjuvants, solvents or other pesticide components can be included). ATAT calculations for all countries will use the same set of toxicity values in the form of Regulatory Threshold Levels (RTLs [23]). These RTL values are derived by (i) collating acute and chronic ecotoxicity endpoint values (e.g., LC₅₀, EC₅₀, NOEC, etc.) for each pesticide active ingredient for each species within a group; (ii) applying methodologies in established regulatory frameworks, such as safety factors [22,23]; and (iii) selecting the worst case value (after applying safety factors) as the RTL.
12. Total Applied Toxicity (TAT [28]) is a measure that sums up weighted pesticide use (in kg) in a country and year, whereby each amount of pesticide used is weighted by the respective pesticide’s toxicity (RTL) for a species group (in different units, e.g., μg/L for aquatic invertebrates or μg/individuum for pollinators). There is one TAT value per country, year and species group (n = 9). TAT values for different species groups cannot be compared directly.
13. Aggregated Total Applied Toxicity (ATAT) summarizes the TAT values for the nine species groups calculated for a country and year into a single value. It does so by comparing the TAT values to baseline TAT values, allowing the indicator to track progress against the targeted reduction (i.e., 50% according to target 7b) per species group. This yields a relative measure, e.g., a value of 100 indicates that the TAT equals the baseline TAT, a value of 50 that the TAT was reduced to 50% of the baseline TAT. The ATAT is calculated as the average of the nine TATs, but it also ensures that the value indicating target achievement (= 50) can only be reached if all species groups are covered (see paragraph 3 above). There is one ATAT value per country and year.
14. The calculation of TAT for species group sp and year t was described by Schulz et al. (2021)[28] as:
where the 𝑇𝐴𝑇𝑠𝑝,𝑡 is the sum of the mass m of a pesticide s applied within one year divided by the toxicity of the pesticide (RTL, Regulatory Threshold Level) for a species group sp. TAT is summed up over n pesticides (up to, about 600 required for ATAT calculations). With nine species groups, each country calculates nine TAT values per year. A set of RTLs will be made available to be used for this equation. 15. A baseline TAT per species group represents the status of the TAT at the beginning of the decade. This is calculated as the arithmetic mean of TAT values for the number of years T for which data is available during the period between 2011 and 2020, inclusive (equation 2). Whereas 10 full years of data is recommended, if data availability does not allow the calculation of TAT for the ten years prior to 2021, then a different number of consecutive years can be used to calculate the baseline TAT; however, this should not be less than three. Each country is required to calculate a baseline TAT per species group (i.e., nine in total). The baseline TAT is calculated as:
16. TAT values calculated per species group need to be expressed relative to the respective baseline TAT (TAT index, equation 3). The proportion between TAT and baseline TAT is scaled by a factor of 100 so that a value of 100 indicates that the TAT equals the baseline TAT, and a value of 50 means that the TAT is half the baseline TAT (= target achievement).
17. The ATAT value for a country and year is calculated according to equation 4. ATAT is expressed as the average TAT index over all nine species groups as
Individual TAT indexes of less than 50 are capped at 50. This ensures that the overall reduction covers all species groups and thereby represents the diversity component of biodiversity (see paragraph 4 above)
18. Each country can calculate yearly ATAT values using national data on pesticide outdoor use by active ingredient. Where such data is unavailable at an active-ingredient level, pesticide use can be estimated based on, in order of preference, (1) sales, (2) imports (= amounts of individual active ingredients imported into the country in kg), plus production (= amounts of individual active ingredients produced in the country in kg), minus exports (= amounts of individual active ingredients exported from the country in kg) or (3) based on applied area (including agricultural land, treated forests, locust control, vector management, aquaculture, etc.) and application rates (see 5e Data sources). The method of pesticide use data collection should be indicated at the time of reporting.
19. The methodology for calculating TAT is available as supplementary information in a paper by Schulz et al. (2021)[28]. The method has already been applied to compare trends in environmental toxicity for key species groups across countries and years [25,27-29,46]. The ATAT builds on the TAT by recommending standard inputs to be used, including species groups, pesticide use, and toxicities to allow comparisons between regions, countries and years
20. ATAT calculations require national/country data on the use of pesticide active ingredients. Disaggregated, open-source, national statistics on pesticide use are not accessible in many countries; however, data on pesticide use by type are generally recorded on an annual basis in many countries, if not publicly reported. Data on pesticide use are reported by countries in an aggregated form (by chemical group and pesticide type by country) to FAO and disseminated through FAOSTAT [46]. Some countries publicly report pesticide use, sales or trade through government ministries. Where necessary, national biodiversity coordinators can source information on pesticide use from relevant ministries, or estimate use based on available sales, import, export and production data as outlined in section 5c
21. Forestry and agricultural areas, disaggregated by crop or livestock species, are often collected on an annual basis by agricultural or trade ministries. Data on crop production (crop types, harvested area, yields), required for improved pesticide use estimates, in cases where use and sales data are absent, are available for most countries from FAOSTAT. Some data may also be available through national reporting authorities, often in a more disaggregated form. Commercial pesticide use data based on surveys might be another source of data [29]. To avoid differences in the parameters used during calculation of ATATs and, thereby, possible biases during the calculations, countries will need to apply a standard set of RTL values (for each active ingredient for each species group) that are deemed suitable for the global indicator. These RTLs will be made available to end users.
22. Further data on pesticide toxicity is freely available through the Pesticide Properties DataBase (PPDB). The PPDB holds data for circa 2,500 pesticide active substances and over 700 metabolites, with circa 320 parameters (e.g., toxicity, biodiversity risk assessments, etc.) stored for each substance [44. The PPDB is publicly available and is used worldwide to support pesticide risk assessments, models and indicators, policy focused monitoring exercises, and general research.
The PEST-CHEMGRIDS dataset [37] provides a publicly accessible, georeferenced dataset of pesticide application rates specific to major and aggregated crops. CROPGRIDS is a global georeferenced dataset providing the distribution, harvested area, and physical area of crops [37,47]
23. The ATAT indicator was proposed by a group of technical and policy experts at a dedicated meeting in FAO (Rome) in January 2024 as a robust indicator that meets the criteria for tracking risk reduction to biodiversity from pesticides. Whereas TAT was already available for use, the methodology for aggregating TAT values for a range of species groups was not yet finalized. The equations for ATAT calculation as presented above have subsequently been developed together with a group of experts in pesticide risk indicators to be made available at SBSTTA-28.
24. Following extensive testing of the TAT and ATAT methodologies by the group of experts and facilitated through FAO, a final methodology and protocol for the application of ATAT relevant to indicator 7.2 was submitted to the CBD in March 2026. The methodology, based on pesticide use, and recognizing that some countries might estimate use based on sales or trade data, inherently incorporates crop, forest and other production areas, and therefore, does not require normalization by area for the purposes of the indicator. Furthermore, based on the availability of pesticide toxicity data and the underlying laboratory methods used to estimate toxicities, including the exposure of a limited number of test/target species as recommended by relevant testing authorities (e.g., OECD), the methodology does not apply weightings based on priorities, endemicities or species richness, to any of the nine species groups used as indicator taxa. Furthermore, although pesticide (active ingredient)-specific data is sometimes incomplete to varying degrees across indicator taxa; the selected species groups have been recommended to allow a broad overview of potential component risks related to the full range of pesticide types (i.e., herbicides, insecticides, fungicides, etc.).
25. The 2011-2020 baseline should be provided during initial reporting (see section 5b) with comparative risks and risk reductions for each year reported from 2022 to 2030. To avoid biases, all parameters used to calculate baseline values must concur with parameters used during the calculation of annual ATATs.
26. Changes to national protocols for collecting data on pesticide use (or data on pesticide trade where use is estimated) may occur over the baseline years (2011-2020) or during the reporting period (2022-2030). Protocol changes can disproportionately affect the estimated total toxicities for certain species groups, thereby distorting the component contributions to the overall ATAT values. Data collection protocols should be standardized across the reporting periods; however, if changes to protocols do occur, their effects on each species group should be investigated (i.e., pre- and postchange), noted and accommodated through a reassessment of the data to ensure standardization across reported years. Changes in data collection should be recorded by relevant national reporting authorities to better inform potential risk mitigation actions.
27. Data on pesticide use may be available through national governments. Pesticide use data is sometimes available through trade and commodities agencies, including private sector agents. Where pesticide use is estimated, data on pesticide trade, including import, export and production may be available through relevant government authorities, including customs, ministries of trade and/or industry. Monash University and the University of Sydney can provide pesticide use estimation services to countries. Data on crop production, including acreage, is available through relevant ministries, including agriculture, forestry, and others. FAOSTAT maintains a publicly accessible database on crop production by country. The RTL values needed to calculate the ATAT will be made available to end users (e.g., via the PPDB). These values must be used by all countries when calculating their ATAT.
28. ATATs are reported to the CBD by relevant national authorities. It is recommended that the data used to calculate TATs and ATATs is maintained by each country's authority. Individual TAT values as well as the contributions to TAT values by specific pesticide active ingredients represent important component indicators that can support the drafting of risk mitigation plans. For example, the top five pesticide active ingredient contributors to overall TAT values can be noted to develop regional and/or national strategies for risk mitigation.
29. The indicator is non-cumulative and not dynamic in time—that is, it does not consider the effects of accumulated pesticides and their degradation products in the environment over time and thus may not fully capture the pervasiveness of active ingredients in the environment, or their residence times, byproducts and pathways.
30. The indicator does not account for the synergistic or antagonistic effects of pesticide mixtures, which are currently poorly documented and for which useful toxicity data is largely unavailable.
31. The indicator omits illegally traded and illegally used pesticides for which information is largely unavailable, in particular, the indicator cannot include non-reported use of banned pesticides – many of which have severe impacts on key species groups.
32. The indicator does not include the detrimental effects of obsolete pesticide stocks in nations; these are often inadequately stored and can have severe adverse effects on biodiversity and ecosystems.
33. The indicator does not address risk mitigation measures such as avoiding pesticide drift, avoiding riverine habitats, avoiding bird and fish breeding seasons, maintaining distances from water bodies, etc.; it assumes that pesticide transport into non-target ecosystems largely depends on use, as indicated by many studies (see section 4. Rationale).
34. The indicator does not incorporate cascade effects whereby pesticide impacts on one species, or a group of species, has detrimental effects on other community components (species or species groups) despite minimal direct pesticide impacts on the latter (e.g., herbicide impacts on flowering plants affect specialized pollinators or pesticide impacts on chironomid larvae affect fish).
35. The indicator is based on pesticide toxicities to species groups as indicated from mainly laboratory studies using recommended target species; it does not apply weightings for rare or endangered species or species that are endemic to specific countries.
36. The indicator does not include coastal and marine habitats and possible detrimental effects to marine organisms.
37. Data on pesticide use if unavailable, can be substituted using the hierarchical approach outlined in section 5c (data collection methods). Reporting authorities are encouraged to maintain clear records of methods and calculations in such cases; this will better inform relevant national authorities when drafting risk mitigation actions.
Scale of application:
38. Scale of data disaggregation/aggregation: Aggregated by pesticide active ingredients, species and species groups, and crop production areas (including forestry and pastures) or application areas (in the case of public health pesticides)
(a) Global/ regional scale indicator can be disaggregated to national level: Yes
(b) National data is collated to
form global indicator: Yes
(c) National data may be disaggregated to crops or regions if use data at the respective resolution are available to guide mitigation measures at the regional level: Yes
39. Indicator characteristics and calculations are available for national authorities in papers published by Schulz et al (2021) [16], Bub et al (2022)[17] and Wolfram et al (2023) [10]. Data to calculate the indicator is available at national levels including, in many cases, to calculate the baseline indicator (2011-2020) using historical data. Extensions of the TAT for community weighting are not yet published; however, until the methodology is published, national authorities can report component indicators (i.e., 15 or more acute of chronic RTL values for all pesticides combined) with community weighting adjusted retrospectively. Component indicators will include TAT estimates for each species and species group and ATAT estimates for each country. PLIs for key species or species groups [26] are recommended as useful complementary indicators.
40. ATAT is a relative measure, expressed as percentage change against the baseline; as such it allows for convenient aggregation at the global level.
6d.1 Description of the methodology
41. The methodology for TAT and its application in comparing environmental toxicities between regions and over time has been published by Schulz et al. (2021)[28].
6d.2 Additional methodological details
42. None
6d.3 Description of the mechanism for collecting data from countries
43. The ATAT will be reported by Parties choosing to use this indicator through their national reports.
44. ATAT complements SDG 6 and SDG 15, which currently has an emphasis on protected lands and waters; directly contributes to monitoring hazardous pesticide risk reduction under the Global Framework on Chemicals (GFC) target A7 and supports related targets under the Framework (e.g., A5, B6 and D5); IPBES (global and regional assessments, thematic assessments and sustainability); contributes to monitoring implementation of Stockholm, Rotterdam, Basel and Minamata Conventions and the Montreal Protocol. The component indicators further support other key international agreements and mechanisms that address pesticide management.
No
45. The ATAT indicator can be disaggregated by pesticide types (herbicide, insecticide, molluscicide, fungicide, etc.) and their relative contributions to reducing toxicities to all species groups against the baseline. Disaggregation of ATAT by changes due to use of nationally listed highly hazardous pesticides (e.g., those listed under international agreements or with human carcinogenic, mutagenic and adverse effects on reproduction) and the transition to safer alternatives will also be possible. Disaggregation to the component indicators, especially TAT, is necessary to inform policy decisions and/or actions on risk mitigation. Disaggregation to crops or regions within a country is an option, provided that use data at the respective resolution are available, to guide mitigation measures.
46. The ATAT will complement monitoring of Goal B and the implementation of targets 9, 10, 11, 15, and 18 of the Kunming-Montreal GBF and indicators 10.2 ‘progress towards sustainable forest management’ and 18.2 ‘value of subsidies and other incentives harmful to biodiversity, that have been eliminated, phased out or reformed’.
Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO)
Kim-Anh Tempelman ([email protected])
Feedback: UNEP-WCMC is keen to ensure that our data is accurate and up to date. We welcome any feedback on the quality, reliability, and accuracy of the information on this site. If you see any errors or missing information, please get in touch.